From Memorial day to Labor Day, visitors from New York and beyond set sail for the stunning sunsets, beach parties and memorable moments on Fire Island. If you plan on visiting Fire Island, then your plans should start well in advance. With few hotels, most people stay in one of the many beach house rentals dotted across Fire Island.
Whether you want to stay in an oceanfront beach house on Cherry Grove or rent a modernist home in The Pines, we have selected the best options available on the Island.
1. Mauri House
10 guests · 6 bedrooms · 8 beds · 5 baths
Mauri House escape to this resort-like beach house in the Fire Island Pines community. This large beach house has a deep swimming pool, 6 person hot tub and multiple decks (including the famous sunset deck) to go along with the 6 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms and 3 separate living rooms, each with their own food preparation areas and outdoor grills.
The house faces the bay and is located along a quiet path with little foot traffic; yet both the beach and the harbor are only a 10 min walk from the house.
This listing is for an entire private beach house including 6 bedrooms and 5 full bathrooms. There are 3 bedrooms with attached bathrooms. Additionally, the house includes multiple outdoor dining and relaxing areas, including two sunset decks.
2. Oceanfront Landmark
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 beds · 4.5 baths
Oceanfront Landmark is centrally located close to the harbor in the Pines and is an oceanfront luxury rental consisting of 5 “real” above ground and fully appointed Bedrooms/ 4.5 baths – including the glass walled master suite overlooking the Atlantic Ocean; Indoor/outdoor Sonos sound throughout; custom designed furniture throughout; multi zone central air; full chef’s kitchen – carrara marble slab counters and custom cabinetry, 2 sub zero refrigerators, two dish washers and a built-in six-gallon frozen cocktail machine; retractable outdoor awnings, spectacularly grand solar heated pool with diving board and a hot tub;
There is even a Precore elliptical machine at the house for the exercise fanatic in all of us (Unless out for repair, which is not often, the machine that is… haha). From what they tell me NO day off IS the new day off in working out …
The house is well designed to offer you every imaginable amenity in oceanfront beach living – a rare Fire Island Pines weekly rental opportunity.
3. Serenity House
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 beds · 3.5 baths
Serenity House celebrity rented and visited Beautiful Bayfront home in Fire Island Pines. Five bedrooms, gourmet kitchen, large pool, all the amenities one could want or need. Private, serene, practical, and appreciated. Also, great for boaters……
A private, one-of-a-kind beach house on the famed FIRE ISLAND in the exclusive section called THE PINES. We have a boat dock that lets you arrive and depart without anyone knowing you were every here. Or you are a 10 minute walk to the harbor where all the action one could want is there to be had.
4. Modern Pines
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 beds · 4 baths
Modern Pines house is newly renovated with lots of space to lounge by the heated pool, or on the balcony overlooking the Pines. Large living room and a huge kitchen for group dinners. There’s a table on the balcony for outdoor dining, or a marble dining table indoors. Umbrellas by the pool for those who like it shady, and really, who doesn’t? Propane BBQ right off the kitchen. Fully equipped kitchen with everything you could need for a fab dinner.
The best part? One of the bedrooms is located in a completely detached separate cottage on the property, complete with it’s own mini-kitchenette and full bathroom. Perfect if you want to get away from the group.
All of the bedrooms have air conditioning. The bed sizes are on king, one queen and two twin sized beds. There is a safe to lock your valuables.
It’s near the corner of Floral and Bay – a 7 minute walk to the ferry, 10 minutes if you sashay. And obviously it’s only like a minute walk to the beach.
5. Pines Harbor House
8 guests · 4X bedrooms · 6 beds · 3 baths
Pines Harbor House is ideally located next to the Fire Island Pines Harbor, this home is bathed in sunlight through skylights and opens onto a deck with breathtaking sunset views over the bay. This house is just a few steps away from the marina, shopping, dining, nightlife and a quick walk from the beach. The private backyard has a relaxing feel with a huge pool, hot tub and bar shed complimented with an ice-maker. Enjoy your perfect summer escape!
With three bedrooms, this home comfortably sleeps six people. Master bedroom features a queen-size bed, balcony with water views, a desk area, and a spacious en suite bathroom. Two additional bedrooms on the main floor have a clean aesthetic feel, including dressers for storage. You will also enjoy a unique glass-walled cube-shaped cabana located at the water’s edge which can accommodate two additional guests.
Prepare a gourmet dinner in the large, fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, or utilize a BBQ grill on the porch. With high-speed internet access and Wi-Fi, this home can be also used as a remote office. Color-changing Hue lights inside the home and an indoor/outdoor 3-zone Sonos sound system create a festive atmosphere
6. Classic Fire Island House
7 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 beds ·3.5 baths
Classic Fire Island House 10 minute walk from Pines harbor and just steps away from the sandy beaches of FIP, this is renowned architect Horrace Gifford’s 2nd home, originally built in 1962 and thoughtfully restored. Published in design magazines and featured on Pines Modern website.
Sleeps 7 in beds; +2 very sleep-able sofas. Two matching master suites (front and back cabana-style, each with private bathrooms, tvs, comfy queen beds, glass-sliding doors to outside, etc.) + two guest rooms (one queen and one twin, complete with jack-and-jill bathrooms and a third massive rain shower).
Huge living room, dining table for 10, fully-stocked kitchen and pantry for your chef.
The outside includes headed pool, hot tub, outdoor lounge chairs for up to 8, outdoor dining table, big Wolf premium grill and 2 outdoor showers.
7. Ocean Views House
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 beds · 4 baths
Ocean Views House newly renovated beach house with ocean views, perfectly located just seconds away from the ocean and only three blocks from the harbor in Fire Island Pines. Great for entertaining!
The house has 4 Bedrooms & 4 Bathrooms, multiple common spaces, and 2 outdoor decks with a pool and a hot tub, both with ocean views. Heat & A/C units in every room, Wifi, Internet Connected TV and much more to offer.
8. Pines Historic House
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 beds · 2 baths
Pines Historic House Beautiful unique Horace Gilford home in quite area, close to beach and 10 minutes walk from harbor
Updated, 2200 sq ft, home in perfect location.
Large open living room/dining area with wood, burning stove, fully stocked gourmet kitchen with all appliances.
4 bedrooms, 2 full baths (both with indoor/outdoor shower).
Beautiful yard with heated pool and hot tub, Weber gas grill, outdoor dining table and lounge chairs.
A/C in 2 bedrooms.
9. Bay Front Home
6 guests · 3 bedrooms 3 beds · 2.5 baths
Bay Front Home all the amenities in this 3 bedroom spacious + bright home with central AC / heat, large gourmet kitchen, formal dining room (seats 12), open living room with over sized fireplace + beautiful hardwood floors throughout. Great outdoor pool area and hot tub.
One of the most beautiful homes in Fire Island Pines with large outdoor area, in ground pool and hot tub area, and a home entertainment system including an indoor screening room and outdoor speaker system. Indulge in a luxurious vacation!
6 guests · 3 bedrooms 4 beds · 3 baths
Beachcomber is a beautiful sparkling pool to relax by and to keep you cool on those hot Summer days. For those cooler early season nights, there is an inviting hot tub and cozy fireplace to keep you toasty warm. An outdoor shower will help you get squeaky clean al fresco when you return from the beach or the woods, both of which are nearby.
Heated and Sunny Pool
Outdoor shower, hammock
Full bathrooms en suite
Each room opens onto the pool or the garden
King bed master suite, queen bed, and two twins or king