Recommended Vacation Rentals on Fire Island

Fire Island unofficially kicks off its tourist season right after Memorial Day weekend. Most of the vacation rentals we have chosen are in Fire Island Pines, however don't be afraid to broaden your search. There are no cars on the Island and its easy to get from one location to the other!

Pines Oceanfront
On the beach – sleeps 6

Pines Oceanfront Apartment

Charming oceanfront cottage with amazing ocean views. Fall asleep to the sound of the waves crashing on the beach, Large private deck with a sunny pool

Ocean Bay Park home
With Pool – Sleeps 10

Ocean Bay Park home Fire island

Spacious beach cottage is on an oversized, fenced lot with lush vegetation The south facing deck is the perfect spot to lounge in the sun or enjoy a barbecue!

Fire Island getaway
Big Deck – Sleeps 9

Fire Island getaway

Welcome to your perfect Fire Island getaway in Ocean Beach! This home is brand new on the market with fresh renovations for your enjoyment and pleasure.

Fire Island ocean view
Private Pool Sleeps 10

Fire Island ocean view

Huge 30 x 10 ft heated saltwater pool, each bedroom has new 4k smart TV and Blu ray player, Enjoy the incredible ocean views from the master bedroom & upstairs deck!